正当性建构:电子竞技报道的框架与话语分析

doi:10.15942/j.jcsu.2021.05.017

Abstract

Abstract: Using framing analysis and discourse analysis, the present paper examines the trend, frames and discourse practice in e-sports news coverage over the past two decades from 2001 to 2019 and discusses how news coverage has constructedthe legitimacy of e-sports. The results show that positive news coverage one-sports has become the dominant trend over the past 2 decades. Framing analysis reveals that five frames, i.e "unknown territory", "industrial economy", "focus of controversy", "sports events", "industrialtrends"have been used to conceptualize the image and development of e-sports in China, and constructed the image of e-sports in media. Among them, "industrial economy", "sports events", and "industrialtrends"are the major frames have been used to construct the legitimacy of e-sports. Discourse analysis shows that news media have constructed the two main discourses of "industry" and "event"about e-sportsand expressed through such rhetorical devices as metaphor and intertextuality the opinion that e-sports has promoted the development of sports and economy, thereby constructing the legitimacy of e-sports. It is proposed that news media should present the image of e-sports in an objective and comprehensive way. On one hand, the positive image of e-sports should be presented in media to change its social perception of being stigmatized; on the other hand, the shortcomings of e-sports industry should be reported to promote its improvement and standardization.

Key words: e-sports, framing analysis, discourse analysis, legitimacy, social perception

CLC Number:

G80-056

LIU Shuangqing, LIU Xun. Legitimacy Construction: A Framing-discourse Analysis on E-sports News Coverage[J]. Journal of Chengdu Sport University, 2021, 47(5): 106-112.

References

[1] 腾讯电竞.2021中国电竞运动行业发展报告[R].搜狐网2021-6-16.
[2] SUCHMAN M C. Managing legitimacy: strategic and institutional approaches[J]. Academy of Management Review, 1995,20(3):571-610.
[3] 李宗浩,王健,李柏.电子竞技运动的概念、分类及其发展脉络研究[J].天津体育学院学报,2004(1):1-3.
[4] 宗争.电子竞技的名与实——电子竞技与体育关系的比较研究[J].成都体育学院学报,2018,44 (4):1-8.
[5] 丁和根.新闻传播研究中话语分析与框架分析之比较[J].当代传播,2020(6):4-9.
[6] 潘忠党.架构分析:一个亟需澄清的领域[J].传播与社会学刊, 2006(1):17-46.
[7] 托伊恩·梵·迪克.作为话语的新闻[M]. 曾庆香,译.北京:华夏出版社,2003:1.
[8] KUHNE R, WEBER P, SOMMER,K. Beyond cognitive framing processes: anger mediates the effects of responsibility framing on the preference for punitive measures[J].Journal of Communication, 2015,65(2):259–279.
[9] 袁光锋.情感何以亲近新闻业:情感与新闻客观性关系新论[J].现代传播,2017,39(10):57-69.
[10] 张翼南.电子游戏的宜导与堵[N].人民日报海外版,2002-4-27(2).
[11] 李宝进.我国游戏产业步入有序化轨道[N].工人日报,2004-4-28(2).
[12] 诺曼·费尔克拉夫. 话语与社会变迁[M].殷晓蓉,译.北京:华夏出版社,2003:181,179-180,74,94,82.
[13] LECHELER S, BOS L,VLIEGENTHART R. The mediating role of emotions[J]. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly, 2015,92(4), 812–838.
[14] MOERNAUT,R MAST J, TEMMERMAN M. All Climate stories worth telling. salience and positionality at the intersection of news values and frames[J]. Discourse, Context & Media, 2019 28(4),93-111.
[15] RILES J M, SANGALANG A, HURLEY R L, et al. Framing cancer for online news: implications for popular perceptions of cancer[J]. Journal of Communication, 2015,65(6),1018-1040.
[16] 王继晟.E-Sport能“玩”出多大市场[N].市场报, 2001-10-31(5).
[17] 俞芳.电子竞技日趋成熟[N].中国信息报,2005-4-11(T0).
[18] 徐晗溪.电竞玩家,好酷![N].海南日报,2019-8-19(B04).
[19] 费明乾.像玩英超一样玩电子竞技[N].北京商报,2007-8-27(A02).
[20] 李娜.资本涌入电竞行业第二春来了[N].第一财经日报,2014-8-6(B04).
[21] 李国.电竞产业呈井喷之势[N].工人日报,2019-4-17(5).
[22] 薛原.世界电子竞技大赛中国区锦标赛将开战[N].人民日报,2007-4-11(12).
[23] 于长洹.电竞高手约战漫博会[N].东莞日报,2015-8-13(A06).
[24] 李雨潇.推动电竞赛事专业化发展[N].中国文化报,2019-8-26(7).
[25] 李立钧.电子竞技运动的现状、启示与思考[N].中国体育报,2004-1-14(2).
[26] 周健森.游戏高手今后也是运动员[N].北京日报,2006-9-28(6).
[27] 王峰.首批高校电子竞技专业将招生岗位“大缺口”急需人才填补[N].21世纪经济报道,2017-6-27(8).
[28] 中华全国体育总会电子竞技运动项目组.为什么把电子竞技运动列为正式开展的体育项目》[N].中国体育报,2004-1-13(1).
[29] 周志军.青涩的电子竞技:在争议中尴尬徘徊[N].中国文化版,2008-6-20(7).
[30] 姚勤毅.电竞首秀,争议声中的双赢创举[N]？解放日报,2018-8-27(9).
[31] 钟智锦,王友.“王者”的意义:奥运冠军报道的特征与话语中的国家意识(1984-2016)[J].新闻记者,2018(7):73-83.
[32] 赵如涵,罗晨.科技新闻报道中的共识制造:转基因议题的框架与话语分析[J].新闻界,2016(11):15-20.
[33] 郭建斌,王笑一,张馨月.“好消息”:中国大陆“民族新闻”的话语分析——基于中文报纸独龙新闻的讨论[J].新闻记者,2018(10):48-65.
[34] 戴焱淼.电竞简史[M].上海:上海人民出版社,2009:31.
[35] 何威,曹书乐.从“电子海洛因”到“中国创造”:《人民日报》游戏报道(1981-2017)的话语变迁[J].国际新闻界,2018,40(5):57-81.
[36] 埃弗雷特·罗杰斯. 创新的扩散[M].辛欣,译.北京:中央编译出版社,2002:14-17.
[37] 洪建平.娱乐·教育·产业:电子竞技的主流媒介镜像 ———以《人民日报》(1978-2018)为中心[J].成都体育学院学报,2018,44(4):9-23.

Legitimacy Construction: A Framing-discourse Analysis on E-sports News Coverage

PDF (PC)

Knowledge

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

References

Related Articles 10

Recommended Articles

Metrics

Comments

[1]	GAO Qiang, XU Fan, WANG Wei, JI LIU. From “What is Sport” to “What is Philosophy of Sport”——An Inquire from “Whether E-Sports is a Sport” [J]. Journal of Chengdu Sport University, 2023, 49(1): 29-37.
[2]	ZHANG Zhen. Is E-Sports a Sport? Explanation and Solution Based on "Ontological Commitments" [J]. Journal of Chengdu Sport University, 2023, 49(1): 38-44.
[3]	ZHOU Le. "Is E-sports a Sport?": Criticism of Logical Analysis and Thinking Mode Based on "Historical Consciousness" [J]. Journal of Chengdu Sport University, 2023, 49(1): 45-50.
[4]	HONG Jianping, LIU Qingzhen. Network Interaction and Interest Balance in Institutionalization: Research and Judgment of E-sports Events in Hangzhou Asian Games [J]. Journal of Chengdu Sport University, 2022, 48(3): 18-23.
[5]	XU Xiaohan. The Promotion Path, Theoretical Framework and Practical Interest of Foreign E-sports Research [J]. Journal of Chengdu Sport University, 2022, 48(3): 24-28.
[6]	CHEN Yikai. The Realistic Problems and Perspective Turn of Chinese E-sports Academic Research [J]. Journal of Chengdu Sport University, 2022, 48(3): 29-34.
[7]	JIANG Yi, SUN Ke, XIONG Shuang. Cultural Interpretation of E-sports Development Dilemma in China [J]. Journal of Chengdu Sport University, 2022, 48(1): 49-54.
[8]	LE Longfei, LI Ming. Analysis on the Factors Influencing the Governance of E-sports Competition Industry Alliance: A Comparison Based on CEA and CMEL [J]. Journal of Chengdu Sport University, 2020, 46(3): 78-83.
[9]	LI Youqiang, ZHANG Yean. E-sports from the Perspective of Embodiment: Historical Evolution, Conceptual Attributes, and Development Orientation [J]. Journal of Chengdu Sport University, 2019, 45(5): 51-57.
[10]	LIANG Shu, LIANG Wei. Research on Hotspots and development trend of international eSport Literatures [J]. Journal of Chengdu Sport University, 2019, 45(2): 7-14.