质疑与思考:软组织损伤康复中是否应摒弃冷疗？

doi:10.15942/j.jcsu.2022.01.020

成都体育学院学报 ›› 2022, Vol. 48 ›› Issue (1): 123-128.doi: 10.15942/j.jcsu.2022.01.020

质疑与思考:软组织损伤康复中是否应摒弃冷疗？

王姿入, 倪国新

北京体育大学,北京 100084

收稿日期:2021-11-10 修回日期:2021-12-10 出版日期:2022-01-15 发布日期:2022-01-30
通讯作者: 倪国新,博士,教授,主任医师,博士研究生导师,研究方向:肌肉骨骼系统康复。E-mail: fjrehab@163.com。
作者简介:王姿入,博士研究生,研究方向:运动损伤与康复。E-mail:rujennifer0808@outlook.com。

Questioning and Thinking: Should Cold Therapy Be Abandoned in the Rehabilitation of Soft Tissue Injuries?

WANG Ziru, NI Guoxin

Beijing Sport University, Beijing 10084

Received:2021-11-10 Revised:2021-12-10 Online:2022-01-15 Published:2022-01-30

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 冷疗常被用于急性软组织损伤后的即时治疗,但由于其可能会延迟损伤部位愈合和恢复过程等不利影响,在实际应用中是否应该被摈弃成为了运动医学与康复医学领域极其关注的话题。文章对冷疗(尤其是传统冷疗方式)在软组织损伤康复中应用的相关质疑进行了总结与分析:包括冷疗的局部降温效果,冷疗对组织恢复与再生过程的影响,冷疗对机体功能表现的影响。文章指出,学界目前对冷疗有效性的争议多基于低质量的、异质性的文献,或来自于动物实验的证据。冷疗处方相关参数(如持续时间、应用频率等)的确定是寻求最佳冷疗方案的基础。建议进一步通过高质量研究验证冷疗疗效,并持续寻求可替代传统手段的新冷疗方法。

关键词: 冷疗, 软组织损伤, 急性损伤康复, 运动医学, 康复医学

Abstract: Cold therapy has been always utilized as an immediate treatment after acute soft-tissue injury. However, due to its potential negative effects on delaying the healing and recovery process of the injured site, whether it should be discarded in the clinical practice in the treatment of acute injuries has become a hot topic in sports medicine and rehabilitation medicine. This article summarizes the related doubts about the effectiveness of cold therapy, especially traditional cooling application, including its ability to reduce the local temperature, impacts on tissue recovery and regeneration process, and effects on functional performance. Meanwhile, the current article also brings the thought regarding the application of cold therapy and points out that the current controversy over the effectiveness of cold therapy is mostly due to the low-quality or heterogeneous research, or evidence with animal samples. Investigating the key elements related to the prescription of cold therapy (e.g., duration, frequency, etc.) is an important basis for seeking the best guideline of its application. Therefore, it is recommended to further determine the efficacy of cold therapy through high-quality research, and to continue validating new alternative cold modalities.

Key words: cold therapy, soft-tissue injury, acute injury rehabilitation, sports medicine, rehabilitation medicine

中图分类号:

G804.5

王姿入, 倪国新. 质疑与思考:软组织损伤康复中是否应摒弃冷疗？[J]. 成都体育学院学报, 2022, 48(1): 123-128.

WANG Ziru, NI Guoxin. Questioning and Thinking: Should Cold Therapy Be Abandoned in the Rehabilitation of Soft Tissue Injuries?[J]. Journal of Chengdu Sport University, 2022, 48(1): 123-128.

导出引用管理器 EndNote|Reference Manager|ProCite|BibTeX|RefWorks

链接本文: https://cdtyxb.cdsu.edu.cn/CN/10.15942/j.jcsu.2022.01.020

https://cdtyxb.cdsu.edu.cn/CN/Y2022/V48/I1/123

参考文献

[1] CAINE D, CAINE C, MAFFULLI N. Incidence and distribution of pediatric sport-related injuries.Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine[J]. Official Journal of the Canadian Academy of Sport Medicine, 2006,16(6):500-513.
[2] WHITE G E, WELLS G D. Cold-water immersion and other forms of cryotherapy: physiological changes potentially affecting recovery from high-intensity exercise[J]. Extreme Physiol Med, 2013, 2(1):26.
[3] DUBOIS B, ESCULIER J F. Soft-tissue injuries simple need peace and love[J]. Br J Sports Med,2020,54(2):3-5.
[4] LONG B C, JUTTE, L S. 21st century attacks on cryotherapy in sports health care-Clinician beware[J].Athletic Training and Sports Health Care, 2020,12(3): 99-101.
[5] WANG Z R, Ni G X. Is it time to put traditional cold therapy in rehabilitation of soft-tissue injuries out to pasture? [J]World journal of clinical cases, 2021,9(17):4116-4122.
[6] GRANT A E. Massage with ice (cryokinetics) in the treatment of painful conditions of the musculoskeletal system[J]. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 1964, 45:233-238.
[7] HAYDEN C A .Cryokinetics in an early treatment program[J]. PhysTher,1964,44:990-993.
[8] HUBBARD T J, DENEGAR C R. Does cryotherapy improve outcomes with soft tissue injury? [J]Journal of athletic training, 2004,39(3):278-279.
[9] SIQUEIRAL A F, VIEIRA A, BOTTARO M, et al. Multiple cold-water immersions attenuate muscle damage but not alter systemic inflammation and muscle function recovery: a parallel randomized controlled trial[J].Scientific reports, 2018,8(1):1-12.
[10] ERNST E, FIALKA V. Ice freezes pain? A review of the clinical effectiveness of analgesic cold therapy[J]. Journal of Pain Symptom Manage, 1994,9(1):56-59.
[11] PALMIERI R M, INGERSOLL C D, HOFFMAN M A, et al. Arthrogenic muscle response to a simulated ankle joint effusion[J]. Br J Sports Med2004,38: 26-30.
[12] MIRKIN G, HOFFMAN M. The Sports Medicine Book[M]. Boston: Little, Brown and Company, 1978:94.
[13] BLEAKLEY C M, GLASGOW P, MACAULEY D C. PRICE needs updating, should we call the POLICE[J]. Br J Sports Med,2012, 46(4):220-221.
[14] GREGSON W, BLACK M A, JONES H, et al. Influence of cold water immersion on limb and cutaneous blood flow at rest[J]. Am J Sports Med,2011, 39(6):1316-1323.
[15] MAWHINNEY C, JONES H, JOO C H, et al. Influence of cold-water immersion on limb and cutaneous blood flow after exercise[J].Med Sci Sports Exerc, 2013, 45(12):2277-2285.
[16] SILVA M A, CARVALHO T R, CRUZ A C, et al. Effect of timedependentcryotherapy on redox balance of quadriceps injuries[J]. Cryobiology,2016,72: 1-6.
[17] COSTELLO J T, CULLIGAN K, SELFE J, et al. Muscle, skin and core temperature after -110 °C cold air and 8 °C water treatment[J]. PLoS ONE, 2012, 7(11):e48190.
[18] CHESTERTON L S, FOSTER N E, ROSS L. Skin temperature response to cryotherapy[J]. Arch Phys Med Rehabil,2002,83: 543-549.
[19] ZARE P, GHORAISHIAN M, FAGHIH A. A three-dimensional model of transient bioheat transfer in the lower extremity during cryotherapy[J].Journal of engineering in medicine, 2021, 235(12):1413-1420..
[20] OTTE J W, MERRICK M A, INGERSOLL C D, et al. Subcutaneous adipose tissue thickness alters cooling time during cryotherapy[J]. Arch Phys Med Rehabil, 2002, 83(11):1501-1505.
[21] MCMASTER W C, LIDDLE S, WAUGH T R. Laboratory evaluations of various cold therapy modalities (dog)[J]. Am J Sports Med, 1978, 6: 291-294.
[22] MACAULEY D. Ice therapy: how good is the evidence?[J]Int J Sports Med, 2001, 22:379-384.
[23] SINGH D P, BARANI Z, WOODRUFF M A, et al.Effects of topical icing on inflammation, angiogenesis, revascularization, and myofiber regeneration in skeletal muscle following contusion injury[J]. Front Physiol,2017, 8: 93.
[24] ZEMBRON-LACNY A, MORAWIN B, WAWRZYNIAK-GRAMACKA E, et al. Multiple Cryotherapy Attenuates OxiInflammatory Response Following Skeletal Muscle Injury[J]. Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2020, 17(21):7855.
[25] CRYSTAL N J, TOWNSON D H, COOK S B, et al. Effect of cryotherapy on muscle recovery and inflammation following a bout of damaging exercise[J]. Eur J Appl Physiol, 2013,113(10):2577-2586.
[26] RAMOS G V, PINHEIRO C, MESSA S et al.Cryotherapy Reduces Inflammatory Response Without Altering Muscle vRegeneration Process and Extracellular Matrix Remodeling of Rat Muscle[J]. Sci Rep, 2016,6(1):1-12.
[27] DEYHLE M R, GIER A M, EVENS K C, et al. Skeletal muscle inflammation following repeated bouts of lengthening contractions in humans[J]. Front Physiol, 2016, 6:424.
[28] PATTERSON S , UDERMANN B E, DOBERSTEIN S T, et al. The effects of cold whirlpool on power, speed, agility, and range of motion[J]. J Sports Sci Med, 2008, 7: 387-394.
[29] PETROFSKY J S, LAYMON M, LEE H. Effect of heat and cold on tendon flexibility and force to flex the human knee[J]. Med Sci Monit,2013,19: 661-667.
[30] FYFE J J, BROATCH J R, TREWIN A J, et al.Cold water immersion attenuates anabolic signalling and skeletal muscle fiber hypertrophy, but not strength gain, following wholebody resistance training[J]. J Appl Physiol, 2019,127(5):1403-1418.
[31] WASSINGER C A, MYERS J B, GATTI J M, et al. Proprioception and throwing accuracy in the dominant shoulder after cryotherapy[J]. J Athl Train, 2007, 42(1):84-89.
[32] CHEN W L, SHIH Y C, CHI C F. Hand and finger dexterity as a function of skin temperature, EMG, and ambient condition[J]. Hum Factors,2010, 52 (3): 426-440.
[33] COSTELLO J T, DONNELLY A E. Cryotherapy and joint position sense in healthy participants: a systematic review[J].J Athl Train, 2010, 45 (3): 306-316.
[34] DIXON P G, KRAEMER W J, VOLEK J S, et al.The impact of coldwater immersion on power production in the vertical jump and the benefits of a dynamic exercise warm-up[J]. J Strength Cond Res, 2010, 24 (12): 3313-3317.
[35] KRUGER M, DE MAREES M, DITTMAR K H, et al.Whole-body cryotherapy’s enhancement of acute recovery of running performance in well-trained athletes[J]. Int J Sports Physiol Perform, 2015, 10(5):605-612.
[36] BLEAKLEY C M, BIEUZEN F, DAVISON G W, et al. Whole body cryotherapy: empirical evidence and theoretical perspectives[J]. Open Access J Sports Med, 2014, 5:25-36.
[37] MIRANDA J P, SILVA W T, SILVA H J, et al.Effectiveness of cryotherapy on pain intensity, swelling, range of motion, function and recurrence in acute ankle sprain: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials[J]. Physical therapy in sport. 2021, 49:243-249.
[38] KWIECIEN S Y, MCHUGH M P. The cold truth: the role of cryotherapy in the treatment of injury and recovery from exercise[J]. European journal of applied physiology, 2021, 121(8):2125-2142.
[39] IHSAN M, WATSON G, LIPSKI M, et al. Influence of postexercise cooling on muscle oxygenation and blood volume changes[J]. Med Sci Sports Exerc, 2013, 45(5):876-882.
[40] FERREIRA-JUNIOR J B, BOTTARO M, VIEIRA A, et al. One session of partial-body cryotherapy (- 110 °C) improves muscle damage recovery[J]. Scand J Med Sci Sports, 2015, 25(5):524-530.
[41] KRUEGER M, COSTELLO J T, ACHTZEHN S, et al. Whole-body cryotherapy (- 110 °C) following high-intensity intermittent exercise does not alter hormonal, inflammatory or muscle damage biomarkers in trained males[J]. Cytokine, 2019, 113:277- 284.
[42] MULLANEY M J, MCHUGH MP, KWIECIEN S Y, et al.Accelerated muscle recovery in baseball pitchers using phase change material cooling[J].Medicine& science in sports & exercise, 2021, 53(1):228-235.
[43] KWIECIEN S Y, O’ HARA D J, MCHUGH M P, et al. Prolonged cooling with phase change material enhances recovery and does not affect the subsequent repeated bout effect following exercise[J]. Eur J Appl Physiol, 2020, 120(2):413-423.
[44] CLUZEAU C. Douleurs et cryothe′rapiehyperbare[J].Ann Kine′sithe′rapie, 2002, 1:30e1
[45] MOUROT L, CLUZEAU C, REGNARD J. Hyperbaric gaseous cryotherapy: effects on skin temperature and systemic vasoconstriction[J]. Arch Phys Med Rehabil,2007,88: 1339-1343.
[46] CHATAP G, DE SOUSA A, GIRAUD K, et al. Acute Pain in the Elderly Study Group. Pain in the elderly: Prospective study of hyperbaric CO2 cryotherapy (neurocryostimulation)[J]. Joint Bone Spine,2007,74: 617-621.
[47] TITTLEY J, H EBERT L J, ROY J S. Should ice application be replaced with neurocryostimulation for the treatment of acute lateral ankle sprains?[J]. J Foot Ankle Res,2020,13(1): 1-11.

质疑与思考:软组织损伤康复中是否应摒弃冷疗？

Questioning and Thinking: Should Cold Therapy Be Abandoned in the Rehabilitation of Soft Tissue Injuries?

PDF (PC)

可视化

摘要/Abstract

引用本文

使用本文

参考文献

相关文章 4

编辑推荐

Metrics

本文评价

[1]	王武浩, 张广鹏, 谢海江, 曲芃豫, 曲芃橙, 王西湖, 宗维洁. 坐式太极拳对Brunnstrom Ⅱ期脑卒中患者上肢运动功能的影响研究[J]. 成都体育学院学报, 2023, 49(2): 82-87.
[2]	胡毓诗, 廖远朋, 孙君志, 丁海丽, 李顺昌. 新冠肺炎疫情对运动医学学科的影响和启示[J]. 成都体育学院学报, 2020, 45(4): 16-19.
[3]	李雪, 李顺昌, 孙君志, 李宁. 聚焦运动科学前沿热点关注大众健身发展现状共探竞技体育科技助力——2019年第二届运动医学与健康学术会议综述[J]. 成都体育学院学报, 2019, 45(6): 8-13.
[4]	汪敏加,廖远朋,郭莹莹. 运动与老年人健康促进研究进展——第64届美国运动医学会年会启示[J]. 成都体育学院学报, 2018, 44(2): 104-108.